The article that I chose to analyze was Diagnosing Drama: Grey's Anatomy, Blind Casting, and the Politics of Representation. This article was published in the Journal of Popular Culture in 2011 and was written by Amy Long.
This article focuses on the “race blind” casting behind the show Grey’s Anatomy and the politics that are involved in the show. The shows creator Shonda Rhimes, wrote the initial pilot episode without character descriptions, other than sex. This lack of character descriptions allowed the show to be cast without specific information about the race of the actors. This allowed for the casting of the show to be done without race in mind and actually resulted in a diverse cast. (Long, 2011)
This article also focuses on the politics behind the show and the effects that those politics have had on the show. The shows main focus is the “fairy tale” happy ending. This is dramatized on the show through the relationships of the two main characters Meredith Grey and Derek Shepherd. Although the relationship of these two characters has been tumultuous throughout the show, they have ultimately continued to end up together. This idea of a fairy tale happy ending is also challenged throughout the show. In one episode Meredith drowns and although Derek finds her in the water, he is unable to save her life and become her “knight in shining armor.” This fairy tale ending is also challenged by the instability of the relationships with the rest of the cast. The cast has had its fair share of relationship problems and though this article was only referencing the first three seasons, these relationship problems continue throughout the show. (Long, 2011)
The final point of the article focuses on the conflicts between the actors on the show. Near the end of season two of the show two of the actors, Isaiah Washington and T.R. Knight, were involved in an altercation where Washington mad reference to Knight with a homosexual slur. Despite the blind casting of the show, the show was not without the drama that many other shows face. (Long, 2011)
The article is written for any audience. The information within the article is specific enough that those who know about the show would be able to understand the content described within the article. Those who had previous understanding of the shows content could also understand the article. The article contained references to the shows origin, description of its characters and additional notes at the end to supplement the contents of the article. (Long, 2011)
I believe that the main idea behind this article is that race affects every aspect of life even when you try to avoid it. Throughout the show the fairy tale ending never seems to happen for those who are not the traditional fairy tale characters. The fairy tale ending has still been difficult for the main characters of the show to attain. Meredith and Derek have been faced with him still being married, her death, his wife moving to Seattle, her nearly being killed by a bomb, him being shot, miscarriages, and losing their adopted child. Throughout this they have continued to return to their relationship but it’s not quite the happy ending that is idealized through fairy tales. (Long, 2011)
I agree with the main points that the author of this article has made. The article provides interesting and in depth information about the politics, drama, and relationships behind the show. Despite these factors the show has continued to thrive and is now into it’s eighth season. The show has helped the ABC network to receive high marks by civil rights groups for the interracial cast of the show. (Long, 2011)
The article is not a very important article in my opinion. Although it was interesting to read and think about this topic, there isn’t much value gained from reading the article. The article may be of value to those who are interested in civil rights or race relations. (Long, 2011)
References:
LONG, A. (2011). Diagnosing Drama: Grey's Anatomy, Blind Casting, and the Politics of Representation. The Journal of Popular Culture, 44(5), 1067-1084. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5931.2011.00888.x